Practical Consequences of the Annulment of the Minute of the General Meeting of Partners for Third Parties

Authors

  • Sandro-Giorgi Sarukhanishvili

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.60131/jlaw.2.2023.7701

Keywords:

Minutes of the General Meetings, Decision of the Partner, General Meeting, Annulment of the General Meeting.

Abstract

The General Meeting is a critical governmental body of the capital companies. The decision of the general meeting is a legal document of great consequence; however, the significance of the minutes of the general meeting depends on the ownership structure. The general meeting and the minutes of the general meeting are the main legal activities of the company that have legal consequences for partners as well as third parties in the obligation relationship with the companies. Furthermore, private and public establishments have no unified practice on which transactions of the corporation require the decision of the general meeting and which do not. The separate article of the consolidated law on Entrepreneurs of Georgia regulates the possibility of the rescission of the decision of the general meeting, in the case the partner attends the general meeting and does not give his/her consent to the decision. The purpose of the paper is to determine the judicial practice and juxtapose it with the scientific theory, in particular, to what extent the judicial practice and the theory are close to each other and what consequences it may have in future; the main question arises if third parties will be able to protect their rights and ensure the continuance of the obligatory relationship in case of the annulment of the minutes of the general meeting. The paper discusses the nature and characteristics of the general meeting and the formal and substantial grounds for invalidating the decision of the general meeting; the article examines the judicial practice regarding the relevance of the annulment of the minutes of the general meeting. 

Author Biography

Sandro-Giorgi Sarukhanishvili

Ph.D. student of Sulkhan-Saba Orbeliani University.

References

Law of Georgia on Entrepreneurs, Legislative Herald of Georgia 875-Vრს-Xმპ, 02/08/2021.

Directive (EU) 2017/1132 of the European Parliament and of the Council Relating to Certain Aspects of Company Law (Codification), Official Journal of the European Union, Document 32017L1132, 2017, http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2017/1132/oj [04.07.2023].

Council Regulation (EC) No 2157/2001 of 8 October 2001 on the Statute for a European company (SE), https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2001/2157/oj [04.07.2023].

Civil Procedure Code of Georgia, Parliamentary Gazette, 47-48, 31/12/1997.

Civil Code of Georgia, Parliamentary Gazette, 31, 24/07/1997.

Law of Georgia on Entrepreneurs, Legislative Herald of Georgia, 21-22, 28/10/1994 [Invalid Legal Act since 02.08.2021].

Burduli I., Makharoblishvili G., Tokhadze A., Zubitashvili N., Aladashvili G., Maghradze G., Egnatashvili D., Corporate Law, 1st ed., Tbilisi, 2021, 316, 321-323, 325, 327-330 (in Georgian)

Bakakuri N., Gelter M., Tsertsvadze L., Jugeli G., Corporate Law, Tbilisi, 2019, 37-50, (in Georgian).

Brožová S., The Nature and Legal Effects of Shareholders Agreements in the Czech and Slovak Private Law and its Interpretation, European Scientific Journal, Vol. 15, No. 31, 2019, 4.

Catea R., Practical Aspects Regarding the Claim for the Annulment of the Resolutions of the General Meeting of Shareholders, from a Substantial and Procedural Perspective, Lex ET Scientia International Journal, No. 24, Vol. 2, 2017, 16.

Chanturia L., Corporate Governance and Liability of Directors in Corporation Law, Tbilisi, 2006, 305, (in Georgian).

Chanturia L., Ninidze T., Commentary on Law of Georgia on Entrepreneur, 3rd ed. Tbilisi, 2002, 117, 305, (in Georgian).

Commentaries on the Civil Code of Georgia, Book II, Law of Things, Chanturia L. (ed.), Tbilisi, 2018, 530, (in Georgian).

Daghie D., Considerations on the Annulment of the Resolution Issued by the General Meeting of Shareholders, Conference Paper: Supplement of Valahia University Law Study, Stan M. (ed.), Târgoviște, 2019, 143.

De Jong A., Mertens G., Roosenboom P., Shareholders’ Voting at General Meetings: Evidence from the Netherlands, ERIM Report Series, 2004, 3.

Gaina V., Gaina A., The Legal Regime of the Decisions Adopted by the General Assembly of Members/Shareholders of the Commercial Company (GAM), Conference Paper: Supplement of Valahia University Law Study, Stan M. (ed.), Târgoviște, 2017, 241, 242, 249.

Jugeli G., Giguashvili G., Commentaries on the Draft Law of Georgia on Entrepreneur (Edition of 09.02.2021), Tbilisi, 2021, 42, (in Georgian).

Laprade F.M., Rights and Obligations of Shareholders, National Regimes and Proposed Instruments at EU Level for Improving Legal Efficiency, Study of Directorate-General for Internal Policies of European Parliament, 2012, 59, 98, 106.

Makharoblishvili G., Dogmatic-Theoretical Separation of Entrepreneurial Entities on the Foundation of Capital Companies, Journal of Law, №2, 2011, 107-108, (in Georgian).

Miller S.K., Minority Shareholder Oppression in the Private Company in the European Community: A Comparative Analysis of the German, United Kingdom, and French Close Corporation Problem, Cornell International Law Journal, Vol. 30, No. 2, 1997, 385, 386.

Partsvania M., Contra Legem: Interpretation: A Curious Decision from the Practice of Administrative Legal Proceedings, Journal “Legal Methods”, №3, 2019, 58, 99, (in Georgian).

Penner J., The Individuation of the Law of Property, New York, 1997, 38.

Rhee R.J., The Tort Foundation of Duty of Care and Business Judgment, Notre Dame Law Review, Vol. 88, No. 3, 2013, 1142, 1183, 1184.

Sáez M.I., Riaño D., Corporate Governance and the Shareholders' Meeting: Voting and Litigation, European Business Organization Law Review, Vol. 14, No. 3, 2013, 368, 373, 375, 390.

Shareholders’ Duties, Birkmose H.S. (ed.), Wolters Kluwer, 2017, 355.

Sikorska-Lewandowska A., The Legal Nature of Resolutions of the Governing Bodies of Companies and Their Challengeability in the Light of the Provisions of Polish Law, Acta Iuris Stetinensis, Vol. 27, No. 3, 2019, 153.

Smanio I., Admissibility of Using the Provisions of the Polish Civil Code as a Basis for Declaring Resolutions of Meetings of Capital Companies Invalid, Prawo i Więź, No. 35, Vol. 1, 2021, 29, 36.

Spasevski D., General Meeting of Shareholders According to the Legal Framework of Germany, United Kingdom and North Macedonia, Iustinianus Primus Law Review, Vol. 10, No. 1, 2019, 11.

Udrescu D., Theoretical and Practical Aspects Concerning the Causes for Annulment of GMS Decisions, The Annals of “Dunarea de Jos” University of Galati Fascicle I, Economics and Applied Informatics, Vol. XV, No.2, 2009, 847.

Uliasz R., Procedural Flaws of Shareholders’ Resolutions – A Comparative Approach, Review of European and Comparative Law, Vol. 51, No. 4, 2022, 95-96.

Van der Elst C., Shareholder Rights and Shareholder Activism: The Role of the General Meeting of Shareholders, Annals of the Faculty of Law - Belgrade Law Review: Journal of Legal and Social Sciences, Vol. 59, No. 3, 2012, 54-57, 63.

Zurabiani L., Essence, Function and Reception of the Business Judgment Rule in the Corporate Law of Georgia, German-Georgian Journal for Comparative Law, №5, 2020, 41.

Zurabishvili T., Qualitative Methods in Social Research, Tbilisi, 2006, 6-7, (in Georgian).

Case C 520/21, Arkadiusz Szcześniak v. Bank M. SA [CJEU], Opinion of Advocate General Collins, delivered16 February 2023(1).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1416-2022, 07.02.2023, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1353-2022, 23.01.2023, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-979-2022, 27.12.2022, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-310-2022, 16.12.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-868-2021, 20.10.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-477-2020, 20.10.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-54-2022, 28.09.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-502-2020, 27.09.2022, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-48-2022,16.09.2022, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-558-2021, 26.06.2022, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Panel of Civil Cases of the Tbilisi City Court, Case №2/27085-21, 03.06.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-73-73-2018, 23.03.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1251-2021, 11.02.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1199-2019, 20.01.2022, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-896-2019, 30.11.2021, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-731-2021, 30.09.2021, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1252-2020, 29.09.2021, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-354-2021, 25.06.2021, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1319-2018, 21.05.2021, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1417-2018, 16.11.2020, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-197-2020, 16.10.2020, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1841-2019, 30.09.2020, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Civil Chamber of the Court of Appeals, Case №2ბ/2309-2019, 25.12.2019, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Civil Chamber of the Court of Appeals, Case №2ბ/90-19, 25.12.2019, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-559-2019, 04.12.2019, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1077-2018, 21.11.2019, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1059-2019, 20.09.2019, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-33-33-2018, 02.08.2019, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1141-2018, 30.11.2018, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-1412-1332-2017, 14.11.2018, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-687-658-2016, 06.11.2018, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-851-795-2017, 20.04.2018, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-612-571-2017, 28.07.2017, (in Georgian).

Judgement of the Chamber of Civil Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia, Case №ას-863-813-2015, 17.12.2015, (in Georgian).

Decision of the Constitutional Court of Georgia on the Case №1/1/543 “Metalinvest LLC” v. the Parliament of Georgia, 29.01.2014, (in Georgian).

The Response of the National Agency of Public Registry of the Ministry of Justice of Georgia, № 112768(original is kept to the Author), (in Georgian).

Deep Interviews with LLC Index were conducted on the 15th of May 2023 (original is kept to the Author), (in Georgian).

Deep Interviews with the employees of the TBC JSC were conducted from the 27th of Mart to the 3rd of April of 2023 (original is kept to the Author), (in Georgian).

https://bit.ly/3ZUdlvy [09.04.2023].

Published

2023-12-30

How to Cite

Sarukhanishvili, S.-G. (2023). Practical Consequences of the Annulment of the Minute of the General Meeting of Partners for Third Parties. Journal of Law, (2). https://doi.org/10.60131/jlaw.2.2023.7701

Issue

Section

Articles